The IOC speaks of political neutrality while turning a blind eye to the manipulation of sports institutions, the exclusion of independent athletes and the growing influence of ideological regimes.
The Iranian regime has exploited the seemingly democratic mechanisms of international sport to consolidate its political influence, while stripping those same mechanisms of their democratic substance at home.
This contradiction is evident on three levels. The engineering of sports democracy within Iran, the transformation of sports representation into an instrument of international influence, and the use of the International Olympic Committee’s principle of political neutrality as a shield against accountability.
This raises a fundamental question. Are the IOC and the international sports federations operating within its Olympic framework responsible only for maintaining political neutrality in sport, or do they also have a duty to prevent governments from capturing sports institutions and turning athlete representation into an instrument of political power?
Answering this requires a closer examination of the record of an organisation that presents itself as the guardian of Olympic values.
The history of IOC presidencies suggests that, at many critical moments, the organisation has preferred to avoid direct confrontation with authoritarian governments and discriminatory policies.

There have, of course, been exceptions. One notable example was the exclusion of South Africa from the Olympic Games in response to the country’s apartheid system. It demonstrated that the IOC could take action against institutionalised discrimination.
During Thomas Bach’s presidency, there were also instances in which the IOC adopted positions suggesting that it could go beyond the general language of political neutrality. However, these interventions failed to establish a consistent and lasting approach to defending athletes’ rights.
From the era of Juan Antonio Samaranch to subsequent presidencies, and now under Kirsty Coventry, the central issue remains the IOC’s willingness to use its institutional authority when governments violate athletes’ rights.
Samaranch, in particular, remains one of the most controversial figures in the history of the organisation. His presidency raises serious questions about the relationship between sport and political power. In the case of Iran, the gradual normalisation of Iranian women athletes competing internationally in Islamic dress, including compulsory hijab, is an issue that deserves closer examination in the history of the IOC’s engagement with the Islamic Republic.
A distinction must be made between a woman’s right to choose what she wears and the imposition of state-mandated dress codes. The issue is not whether an athlete wears a hijab. It is whether she has the right to compete without being forced to wear one.
The Islamic Republic. Exploiting democracy without accepting freedom
Since the 1979 revolution, Iran has been governed by an ideological Islamic system in which sport has not been immune to political and religious interference.
Women’s participation in Iranian sport remains subject to legal, ideological and structural restrictions. Female athletes are required to comply with government-mandated dress codes to compete and pursue professional careers. Their access to sporting facilities and opportunities in certain disciplines is also severely restricted.
Sports facilities and stadiums are, in many cases, operated on a gender-segregated basis. Women are denied access to a number of sporting disciplines and facilities, including swimming, diving and water polo, gymnastics, while their participation in sports such as wrestling, cycling and judo has also faced significant structural obstacles.
Alongside these restrictions, the policy of refusing to compete against Israeli athletes has become a recognised feature of Iranian sport, placing athletes’ careers at the mercy of political decisions. Members of the Baha’i community also face discrimination and exclusion from sporting opportunities because of their religious identity. These practices demonstrate how political and ideological control extends across different sections of Iranian sport.
Despite this record, Iranian sports representatives continue to occupy positions within international sporting institutions, including decision-making bodies and influential commissions.
The contradiction is clear. A system that restricts free competition, independent choice and equality in sport at home can nevertheless use international electoral mechanisms to secure representation and influence abroad.
Engineering sports democracy in Iran
The issue is not simply the presence of government officials in sports administration. It concerns the mechanisms through which candidates for key positions are selected, restricted and ultimately brought into a controlled electoral environment.
Elections for the presidency of the National Olympic Committee of Iran, national sports federations and provincial sports bodies take place within a structure which, according to evidence and information concerning the country’s sports administration, is subject to political and institutional screening.
Under such circumstances, an election does not necessarily amount to free competition. There may be ballots, candidates and official minutes, but the fundamental issue is who is allowed to stand and who is effectively excluded from the process.
The influence of this system extends beyond elections. Those who emerge from these structures play an important role in determining the composition of athletes’ commissions, coaches’ commissions, national teams and the management of sports federations.
Political and administrative control can therefore extend from the top of the system into the sporting community itself. Athletes seeking places on national teams or in prominent clubs are left with little choice but to obey the authorities without question if they wish to continue their sporting careers.
In this way, athlete representation risks becoming an extension of the very management structure it is supposed to scrutinise, rather than an independent mechanism for defending athletes’ rights.
From athletes’ commissions to the corridors of the IOC
The significance of this issue becomes even greater when one considers that athletes’ commissions and electoral mechanisms within international sports institutions provide routes into the Olympic decision-making structure.
If a government can influence elections and the composition of sports representatives at home, it can use the same channels to promote individuals close to its political establishment within international institutions.
Iranian representatives in international sports institutions cannot be viewed in isolation from the political structures that shape sports administration at home. Their electoral networks and institutional connections deserve scrutiny, particularly when the same system that restricts athletes’ independence also determines who represents them abroad.
International sports bodies must look beyond official election results and examine the political structures and interests behind these representatives. Accepting electoral outcomes without examining the conditions under which they were reached risks legitimising a process that may have little to do with genuine democratic representation.
Sports democracy cannot be measured simply by counting votes. The independence of candidates, the freedom of voters and the ability of critics to participate are equally important.
Elnaz Rekabi. When an athlete’s choice collides with state policy
The case of Elnaz Rekabi is a clear example of the conflict between an Iranian female athlete’s independence and the ideological policies of the regime.
Her decision to compete without the compulsory hijab at the Asian Sport Climbing Championships in Seoul in October 2022 triggered a major political controversy. Following her return to Iran, Rekabi came under intense pressure from the authorities. The incident had serious consequences for her life and career, ultimately forcing her to leave the country.
Rekabi’s case is not an isolated one. Iranian women athletes in several disciplines, including football, chess, shooting and taekwondo, have left the country in recent years amid restrictions and pressures associated with government policies and compulsory dress codes.
These cases must be considered within the broader context of state-imposed dress regulations and the denial of women’s freedom of choice.
The IOC’s responsibility cannot be limited to ensuring that Iranian athletes are allowed to compete in clothing approved by their government. It must also address athletes who lose sporting opportunities because they refuse to comply with ideological regulations.
If an athlete’s freedom to choose what she wears is not recognised, the Olympic principles of equality and independence lose their meaning.
Silence that serves those in power
One of the fundamental problems with the IOC’s approach is its narrow interpretation of political neutrality.
Political neutrality should not mean turning a blind eye to discrimination, repression or government interference in the independence of sports institutions. Nor should it become a mechanism through which governments avoid accountability for their treatment of athletes.
The Olympic Charter emphasises the autonomy of the Olympic Movement, opposition to discrimination and respect for human dignity. These principles are not simply statements to be included in official documents. Their credibility is tested when sports institutions are confronted with violations.
When the IOC remains silent about government interference in sports elections, treats the exclusion of independent athletes as an issue beyond its remit and accepts athlete representatives without examining their genuine independence, it effectively legitimises a system that uses the language of democratic representation to consolidate political power.
The IOC must answer a fundamental question
Kirsty Coventry, the current IOC president, is in a position to redefine the organisation’s relationship with the actual rights of athletes.
The issue is not whether the IOC should become involved in domestic political disputes or determine how countries are governed. It is whether the organisation is prepared to accept responsibility when the very principles enshrined in its own Olympic Charter are violated.
Does the autonomy of National Olympic Committees mean only freedom from government interference in administrative affairs, or does it also require genuinely independent elections, independent athlete representatives and freedom of choice for members of national teams?
Should athletes’ commissions serve as independent voices for athletes, or can they become another platform for reproducing the influence of sports administrators and governments?
Ultimately, are the IOC and international federations prepared to examine who enters their decision-making structures in the name of athletes, what their backgrounds are and through which mechanisms they secure their positions?
If political neutrality means indifference to violations of athletes’ rights, it ceases to be an ethical principle. It becomes an administrative tool for avoiding responsibility.
The Olympic Movement cannot continue to speak of democracy, autonomy and the dignity of athletes while remaining silent in the face of mechanisms that hollow out these values from within.
